Are the Requirements for ’Control of Use’ Changing? : Analysis of the ECtHR Judgment in Pannon Plakát Kft and Others versus Hungary

Varga Ádám: Are the Requirements for ’Control of Use’ Changing? : Analysis of the ECtHR Judgment in Pannon Plakát Kft and Others versus Hungary.
HUNGARIAN YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND EUROPEAN LAW, 11 (1). pp. 376-389. ISSN 2666-2701 (2023)

[thumbnail of Varga_Are_the_Requirements_for_Control_of_Use_Changing.pdf]

Szöveg
Varga_Are_the_Requirements_for_Control_of_Use_Changing.pdf - Megjelent verzió
Download (131kB)

Mű típusa:

Folyóiratcikk

Szerző azonosítók:

Név	ORCID	MTMT szerző azonosító
Varga Ádám	0000-0002-2960-0195	10039437

Absztrakt (kivonat):

The present study deals with the judgment of the ECtHR on control of the use of property and the conclusions to be drawn from it. According to ECtHR, disproportionate amendments to an Act on roadside advertising hoardings outside built-up areas have extinguished substantial part of applicant companies’ businesses. The analyzed judgment is especially interesting because it provides a good example of the different approach of the Hungarian Fundamental Law and the ECHR to the examined issue (which concerns not only the right to property in the narrow sense, but also the right to freedom of enterprise), and also strongly demonstrates the importance of the precise establishment of the facts and the correct interpretation of the regulatory context. On the one hand, the judgment summarizes the conclusions of a number of earlier (mainly Hungarian) cases, and on the other hand, it further elaborates the interpretation of the ECHR provision under examination. It can be seen that the interpretation of the control of use is in a period of change. In addition to the general principle of fair balance, the requirement of compensation is increasingly being applied in the case of restrictions that do not amount to a deprivation of property.

Folyóirat címe:

HUNGARIAN YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND EUROPEAN LAW

Megjelenés éve:

2023

Kötet:

Szám:

Oldalak:

pp. 376-389

ISSN:

2666-2701

Intézmény:

Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem

Kar:

Jog- és Államtudományi Kar

Nyelv:

angol

MTMT rekordazonosító:

34122263

Dátum:

2025. Feb. 03. 11:21

Utolsó módosítás:

2025. Feb. 03. 11:21

URI:

https://publikacio.ppke.hu/id/eprint/2151

Actions (login required)

Tétel nézet