Reconciling Jurisdictions in the European System of Constitutional Adjudication : Reform proposals for the CJEU

Csapodi Márton: Reconciling Jurisdictions in the European System of Constitutional Adjudication : Reform proposals for the CJEU.
HUNGARIAN YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND EUROPEAN LAW, 10 (1). pp. 231-245. ISSN 2666-2701 (2022)

[thumbnail of Csapodi_Reconciling_Jurisdictions_in_the_European_System_of_Constitutional_Adjudication.pdf]

Szöveg
Csapodi_Reconciling_Jurisdictions_in_the_European_System_of_Constitutional_Adjudication.pdf - Megjelent verzió
Download (358kB)

Mű típusa:

Folyóiratcikk

Szerző azonosítók:

Név	ORCID	MTMT szerző azonosító
Csapodi Márton	0000-0003-3713-7652	10085403

Absztrakt (kivonat):

Several authors have concluded that an institutional reform of CJEU is necessary, with some putting forward reform proposals accordingly. This paper briefly recounts the reasons why such a reform may be indeed necessary, with due attention to the fact that national constitutional resistance to the Luxembourg court seems to be occurring with increasing frequency. In what follows, I present some of the institutional reform proposals that appeared in the academic discourse and make some critical observations in respect of these ideas. These proposals include: the introduction of a reverse preliminary reference procedure for cases related to national identity; a political override mechanism; a proposal for limiting preliminary reference rights to high courts (albeit with exceptions); and finally, the idea to establish a new court specialized in competence issues. Perhaps the latter proposal is the most popular, although various authors propose substantially different constructions. I conclude that a Subsidiarity Court specialized in competence issues could be an effective instrument for a better representation of national constitutional perspectives at the EU level, which would be essential, should open non-compliance be avoided. I also propose a complementary mechanism to the preliminary reference procedure, which would allow constitutional courts to participate in the European constitutional dialogue.

Folyóirat/kiadvány címe:

HUNGARIAN YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND EUROPEAN LAW

Évszám:

2022

Kötet:

Szám:

Oldalak:

pp. 231-245

ISSN:

2666-2701

Intézmény:

Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem

Kar:

Jog- és Államtudományi Kar

Nyelv:

angol

MTMT rekordazonosító:

33164390

Dátum:

2025. Feb. 03. 10:35

Utolsó módosítás:

2025. Feb. 03. 10:35

URI:

https://publikacio.ppke.hu/id/eprint/2161

Actions (login required)

Tétel nézet